» Subscribe to Newsletter
» Switch to BizTech2.com
Home » Reviews » Home HiFi & TV » Two Blu-ray Players From Sony
Two Blu-ray Players From Sony
By: Siddharth Bhatia   |   Mar 04, 2008
  • 4
Stunning picture quality
Pleasing color levels
Very expensive

Features
Both players have a simple set of connections at the back, namely one HDMI (1.1) out, a single set of analog 5.1 audio, an optical, coaxial audio, and component video out. It’s well-arranged and easy to access. No Ethernet port is present, as these are profile 1.0 only (let’s not expect too much).

These profile 1.1 players play BD ROM, DVD video, DVD-/+RW, audio/MP3 CD, JPEG and AVC HD discs. The S1E also plays rewritable BDs, called BD-R/RE discs. For more on profiles check out this feature.

You get 24p output at full HD (1920 x 1080), which is the closest to the actual movie recording. The players support x.v.Color, which means that the color set conforms to the xvYCC standard, approved by the IEC. They have a 192kHz/24Bit A/D converter, and support DTS/Dolby true HD. Dolby and DTS 5.1 decoders are present and feed through the analog outputs mentioned.

The spec sheet also claims separate circuits for audio and video, but sadly high-end audio like SACD or DVD A aren't supported.

Performance
As you turn the players on, a simple setup option comes up and takes you to the system menu, where you specify the video output. I chose 1080p at 24 frames (yippee!) and slid in a Blu-ray demo disc with lots of HD video content and trailers of movies such as Spiderman 3, Ghost Rider, Surf’s Up. 300 Blu-ray disc was up next, so hang in there...

We used two full HD TVs to make sure display quality is not an issue while checking these high-end sources. The menus at the beginning of the disc look strikingly crisp and clear, with accurate lines and borders. I saw a set of slow-moving still life scenes, to experience full HD resolution bliss, and I was not disappointed in any way. Colors too were excellent on both players. Indeed, so far both players put up more-or-less equal performance.

Motion scenes were another matter. The BD-S1 was spectacular here, with minimal judder, jaggies, moiré patterns etc. Way lesser than anything I've seen; the lower-end BDP-S300 and the PS3 included. This is what you're paying for: ultimate clarity. Brightness/contrast levels could have done with a boost, though this I’m sure was the TV’s fault. Ghosting and slight dot trailing was evident, though this was less of an issue than with normal DVDs and upscaled stuff.

Conclusion
Both players are amazing, though if you are into games the PS3 makes more sense than the BDP-S300, which costs Rs 29,500. The BD-S1E is in another league, and costs Rs 59,500. But I'm sure prices will fall once the competition takes off. Still, those who can afford it can pull out their wallets right now. Oh, and I’ll probably be reviewing an LG next, so do stick around.


Ads by Google 
Post a Comment on “Two Blu-ray Players From Sony”
Comment : 
Name : 
City : 
Email : 
I have already got a PS3......ha.hah.ahah.ha.ahha
Shankar @ Mar 05, 2008
Now you know why the PS3 has a bluray player.With its own BR players priced higher than the PS3 Sony assured that people will buy the PS3 for BR playback.
If you're planning to buy a BR player,i would suggest buying a PS3 as its the only future-proof BR player available in the market.
Ravi Shanker @ Mar 05, 2008
then why the hec is ps3 so cheap then blue ray player..cant understand wats sony up to...in my viwe blue ray will come to 15k in a years time
prashant @ Mar 05, 2008
I'm glad that we have a winner pretty early in this format war. The last thing which was needed is a coexistence of 2 formats which thankfully did not happen. I would rather skip the first generation of bluray drives and wait for better and cheaper priced ones in the coming months.

Those who have purchased a PS3 though, have made a fine investment.
Kartik @ Mar 05, 2008
Thanks, but no thanks.

I am not about to throw away my DVD collection just so that movie studios can make money by selling me more of the same old.

Did you know that audio CDs were designed to hold lossless audio. People don't need (and can't get) better audio from crap like SACD, DVD-Audio, etc.

Hollywood learned a lesson from this and decided never to sell full quality movies to customers. Blu-Ray is no exception. Movies and sound are still encoded using lossy compression algorithms. So, expect a 'new' disc format within ten years which promises better audio and video quality.

However, the killer on this one is the DRM. I will never buy crap infested with DRM.

The increase in quality is not as dramatic as that observed when people watched DVD movies after years of the VHS tape.
Rohan @ Mar 05, 2008
Ads by Google 
Ads by Google
Products
Camcorders  |   Controllers  |   CPUs  |   Desktop PCs  |   Digital Cameras  |   Digital Video Recorders  |   DVD Players  |   Games  |   Gaming Consoles  |   General  |   GPS Systems  |   Handhelds / PDAs  |   Hard Drives  |   Headphones & Headsets  |   HiFi Audio Systems  |   Home Theater Systems  |   Input Devices  |   Internet  |   Laptops  |   lenovo  |   Low Level Components  |   Mac Systems  |   Mobile Phone Accessories  |   Mobile Phones  |   Monitors  |   Motherboards  |   MP3 / Audio Players  |   Multi-Function Devices  |   Networking  |   Optical Drives  |   PC Accessories  |   PC Add-on Cards  |   PC Cabinets  |   PC Games  |   Printers  |   Projectors  |   RAM Modules  |   Scanners  |   Software  |   Speakers  |   Telecom  |   TVs  |   Video Players  |  
Careers | About Us | Ad Inventory | Site Profile | Feedback | Copyright © 2007, Tech2.com India - A Network 18 India Venture